1Craig & Zoe
A man's online accounts are hacked by a woman he met on Facebook in the Season 3 premiere. After meeting Zoe on Facebook, she begins demanding passwords and hacking accounts.
2Antwane & Tony
Carmen is concerned about her cousin Antwane's 3-year romance with a man named Tony. Antwane lives a virtually pre-digital age existence making Tony's true identity difficult to reveal. Is Tony really who he says he is?
3Antoinette & Albert
A year after meeting "T-lights" on Instagram, "instaceleb" Antointette is ready to take things to the next level and meet "T-lights", but he always brushes off the idea. Is "T-lights" really the online celebrity he claims to be?
4Lucille & Kidd Cole
Lucille became affiliated with apparent recording artist Kidd Cole (who claims to have ties with Kanye West and his record label) and his co-manager Miguel who implicate her in a series of events that involve fat payments to the parties concerned.
5Tracie & Sammie
La star Tracie Thoms avait un lien affectif avec un fan nommé Sammie. Mais ce dernier a soudainement disparu sans laisser de trace. Tracie se demande alors qui est vraiment Sammie. Nev Schulman (à l'origine du documentaire CATFISH primé au festival de Sundance) décide, après son expérience malheureuse racontée dans ce documentaire, d'aider des gens tombés amoureux sur le net alors qu'ils n'ont jamais rencontré leur future moitié dans la vraie vie. Après les avoir questionnés et conseillés sur les pièges que peuvent engendrer une relation virtuelle, Nev part filmer LA rencontre, moment crucial où les deux tourtereaux se découvrent enfin en chair et en os. Grosses déceptions à prévoir, ou pas ! Au cours de ces rencontres décisives, le réalisateur s'attache également à découvrir les raisons qui ont poussé ces internautes à catfisher des inconnus sur la toile.
6John & Kelsey
John met Kelsey Beelzebub, whose voice he has heard only once and whom he has never video chatted with, in a psychology chat room. Kelsey claims to have body dysmorphic disorder and anxiety.
7Solana & Elijah
Solana has been in a five-year relationship with Elijah, whom she met on MySpace, since she was 14. Elijah was her rock when she was coming to terms with her parents' divorce, but he abruptly goes off the radar. Around a couple of years later, he reaches out to her via a Facebook message, when Solana is in a relationship with Danny, but says that his gadget does not facilitate phone calls or video chat,so her must resort to a texting app
8Miranda & Cameryn
A woman searches for answers about a man she met online.
9Jeff & Megan
Red flags make a man question his relationship with a woman he met online.
10Bianca & Brogan
When Bianca met Brogan online everything was perfect until Brogan disappeared one day. A year later Brogan reappeared online and Bianca never questioned her. Can Biana find out what happened a year ago?