1Phone-y Business
Magicians Jon Armstrong, Xavier, Greg Dow (aka The Shocker), and Steve Brundage try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
2The Invisi-Ball Thread
Magicians Leon & Romy, Mike Hammer, Shin Lim, and Peter Boie try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
3Shoot to Kill
Magicians Brian Brushwood, Simon Pierro, John Lovick, and Kyle Knight & Mistie try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
4Knife of the Party
Magicians Austin Janik, Amazing Allison, Mac King, and Norman Ng try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
5Mission Impossi-Ball
Magicians Bill Cook, Wes Barker, Matt Holtzclaw, and David Regal try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
6Now THAT'S Bunny!
Magicians Jay Sankey, Greg Wilson, Trigg Watson, and Jen Kramer try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
7Penn's Favorite Card Trick
Magicians Kostya Kimlat, Frederick Falk, Chris Funk, and Nate Dendy try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
8Teller Plays With A Full Deck
Magicians Blake Vogt, Joshua Jay, Levent, and Ben Seidman try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
9Star Spangled Magic
Magicians Riley Siegler, Jade, Ran'd Shine, and David Roth try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
10Where There's Smoke There's Magic
Magicians Joel Meyers & Spidey, Rick Lax, Marcus Eddie, and Bruce Gold try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
11Teller Deflowers a Shadow
Magicians Scott & Puck, Eric Jones, Mark Calabrese, and Paul Vigil try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
12Penn & Teller Ring Someone's Neck
Magicians Victor & Diamond, Francis Menotti, Nash Fung, and Chad Juros try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
13An Egg-Cellent Trick
Season 2 ends with magicians Derek Hughes, Reuben Moreland, Suzanne, and Jared Kopf trying to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.