- 1
Marty Allen and Steve Rossi
- 2
Jerry Herman & Henry Fonda
- 3
Arthur Godfrey (3)
- 4
Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gormé (3)
- 5
Steve Allen (3)
- 6
Clete and Ken Boyer & Phyllis Diller
- 7
Tony Bennett
- 8
Craig Breedlove & James Garner
- 9
Robert Goulet
- 10
Luis Miguel Dominguín & Anne Bancroft
- 11
Elizabeth Ashley
- 12
Buddy Hackett (4)
- 13
Eddie Fisher (3)
- 14
Joan Crawford (2)
- 15
Jack E. Leonard (2)
- 16
Gene Kelly (2)
- 17
Jason Robards
- 18
Lee Remick (2)
- 19
Minnesota Fats & Ann Sothern
- 20
Jack Lemmon (4)
- 21
Jimmy Durante (2)
- 22
Floyd Patterson
- 23
The Panel's Spouses (Phyllis Cerf, Martin Gabel, Dick Kollmar, Jayne Meadows) & Gloria Swanson
- 24
James Mason (4)
- 25
Tommy Sands and Nancy Sinatra
- 26
Lucille Ball (3)
- 27
Alan Arkin, Anne Jackson and Eli Wallach
- 28
Art Carney (3)
- 29
Robert Mitchum (2)
- 30
Maurice Chevalier (2)
- 31
George Jessel (3)
- 32
Marian Anderson
- 33
Barbra Streisand (2)
- 34
Jack Jones
- 35
Soupy Sales
- 36
Liza Minnelli
- 37
Robert Goulet (2)
- 38
Joan Collins and Anthony Newley
- 39
Tallulah Bankhead (2)
- 40
Art Linkletter (2)
- 41
George Hamilton
- 42
Ethel Merman (2)
- 43
Trini López
- 44
Jack Dempsey (2)
- 45
Milton Berle (4)
- 46
Carol Channing and Ginger Rogers & Lucille Ball
- 47
Jill St. John
- 48
Olivia de Havilland (4)
- 49
Allan Sherman (2)
- 50
Steve Lawrence
- 51
Betty Grable