- 1
Bode Miller
- 2
T.J. Miller
- 3
Kyrie Irving
- 4
Jenny Slate
- 5
John Daly
- 6
Nick Thune
- 7
Bo Burnham
- 8
Paul Scheer (Pt. 1)
- 9
Paul Scheer (Pt. 2)
- 10
Devin Logan
- 11
Grace Helbig
- 12
David Wolfe
Pete and one of his writers (Joe DeRosa) test out their alternative "I Can't Believe It's Not Butter" titles.
- 13
Erinn Hamlin & Kate Hansen
- 14
Lauren Cohan
- 15
Harrison Barnes
- 16
Jason Mantzoukas & Anthony Davis
- 17
Rob Riggle
- 18
Gillian Jacobs
- 19
Matt Berninger
- 20
Dikembe Mutombo
- 21
Jay Larson and Ryan Sickler
- 22
Robert Rodriguez
- 23
Ashley Rickards, Jillian Rose Reed, & Molly Tarlov
- 24
Zach Woods
- 25
Adam Scott & Roy Hibbert
- 26
Jim Jefferies & Jamie Lee
- 27
Jessica St. Clair & Lennon Parham
- 28
Retta
- 29
Bob Mankoff
Pete challenges US Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and President Obama to a game of two-on-two against him and Conan.
- 30
Phil Hanley
- 31
Adam Pally
- 32
Kristen Schaal
- 33
Jerrod Carmichael
- 34
Trixie Garcia
- 35
Ben Schwartz
- 36
Kumail Nanjiani
- 37
Kid Ink
- 38
Patton Oswalt
- 39
Thomas Middleditch, Jim Breuer, Matt Braunger
- 40
Nicole Byer, Andy Haynes, Jim Breuer, Matt Braunger
- 41
Joe DeRosa
- 42
Ray Romano
- 43
Big Jay Oakerson
- 44
Natasha Leggero
- 45
Eliza Coupe
- 46
Daniel Sloss
- 47
Ben Schwartz, Karl Koppertop
- 48
Schoolboy Q
- 49
Gary Gulman, Martellus Bennett
- 50
Duncan Trussell
- 51
Joe Manganiello
- 52
Andrew W.K., Scott Hutchison