- 1
Joey Bishop (3)
- 2
Warren Beatty
- 3
Leontyne Price & Peter Ustinov
- 4
Arlene Francis' Broadway Co-Stars in "Dinner at Eight"
- 5
Connecticut Senator Abraham E. Ribicoff & Danny Kaye
- 6
George Hamilton (2)
- 7
Suzy Knickerbocker & Ed Sullivan
- 8
Michael Caine
- 9
Virna Lisi
- 10
Frank Sinatra & Mia Farrow
- 11
Angela Lansbury
- 12
The Panel from 'To Tell the Truth' (Kitty Carlisle, Tom Poston, Peggy Cass, Orson Bean) & George Segal
- 13
Steve McQueen
- 14
Eva Marie Saint (2)
- 15
Gina Lollobrigida (2)
- 16
Jane Fonda (2)
- 17
Abbe Lane
- 18
Herb Alpert and The Tijuana Brass & Vince Lombardi
- 19
The Smothers Brothers
- 20
Chris Noel & Tony Randall
- 21
Yves Montand (2)
- 22
Andy Griffith (4)
- 23
Marty Allen and Steve Rossi (3)
- 24
Jacqueline Susann & Judy Garland
- 25
Jonathan Cerf and Peter Gabel (Sons of Bennett Cerf and Arlene Francis) & Robert Morse
- 26
Vidal Sassoon & Ursula Andress
- 27
Orson Bean & Sid Caesar and Imogene Coca
- 28
Soupy Sales (3)
- 29
Candice Bergen
- 30
Groucho Marx (2)
- 31
Raquel Welch
- 32
Leslie Uggams
- 33
Allan Sherman (3)
- 34
The Supremes
- 35
Lawrence Welk
- 36
Jean Shrimpton & Jack Jones
- 37
Kelly Lange & Melina Mercouri
- 38
F. Lee Bailey & Betty Grable
- 39
Betty Comden and Adolph Green
- 40
Senator Everett Dirksen
- 41
Goodson-Todman Game Show Hosts (Bud Collyer, Allen Ludden, Ed McMahon and Gene Rayburn)
- 42
Lauren Bacall (3)
- 43
Peggy Cass (2)
- 44
Jack E. Leonard (3)
- 45
Woody Allen (3)
- 46
Jill St. John (2)
- 47
Hugh O'Brian (2)
- 48
Last Show - Moderator John Daly is the Mystery Guest