- 1
Sal Maglie and Duke Snider
- 2
Miss America 1955 Lee Meriwether & Alfred Hitchcock
- 3
Robert Young & Gina Lollobrigida
- 4
Red Skelton & Roy Rogers and Dale Evans
- 5
Jeff Chandler
- 6
Fernando Lamas
- 7
Merle Oberon
- 8
Ray Milland
- 9
June Allyson and Dick Powell
- 10
Elizabeth Taylor
- 11
Ginger Rogers
- 12
Herbert Marshall
- 13
Louis Jourdan
- 14
Bob Hope and Clarence Nash (the voice of Donald Duck)
- 15
Dan Dailey
- 16
Edgar Bergen and Charlie McCarthy
- 17
Eve Arden
- 18
Tony Curtis & Bill Talbert
- 19
Esther Williams
- 20
Dennis Day
- 21
Shelley Winters
- 22
Pearl Bailey
- 23
Arkansas Senator John L. McClellan
- 24
Dorothy Lamour
- 25
Portland Hoffa
- 26
Lily Pons
- 27
Sammy Davis Jr.
- 28
Terry Moore
- 29
Tyrone Power
- 30
Fred Astaire
- 31
Rhonda Fleming
- 32
Barbara Ann Scott
- 33
Rosemary Clooney
- 34
Gracie Fields
- 35
"The Incomparable" Hildegarde
- 36
Marge and Gower Champion
- 37
Van Johnson (2)
- 38
The McGuire Sisters
- 39
Conrad Hilton
- 40
Tom Ewell
- 41
Arnold Stang
- 42
José Ferrer
- 43
Audie Murphy
- 44
Sheree North
- 45
Fred Allen (2)
- 46
Robert Q. Lewis
- 47
Ty Cobb
- 48
Burl Ives
- 49
Paul Muni
- 50
Audrey Meadows
- 51
Lilly Dache & Peggy King