- 1
Ralph Bellamy (3)
- 2
Carl Sandburg & Milton Berle
- 3
Cantinflas
- 4
Red Skelton
- 5
Kirk Douglas & Mickey Rooney
- 6
Billy Graham & Anthony Quinn
- 7
Danny Kaye
- 8
Ralph Houk & Janet Leigh
- 9
John 'The Cool Ghoul' Zacherley & Frankie Laine
- 10
Joey Bishop
- 11
John Wayne
- 12
Maurice Evans
- 13
Nancy Kwan
- 14
Stephen Boyd
- 15
Edward G. Robinson (3)
- 16
The Panel's Spouses (Phyllis Cerf, Florence Randall, Dick Kollmar, Martin Gabel)
- 17
Lucille Ball (2)
- 18
Wilt Chamberlain & Joan Crawford
- 19
Henry Fonda
- 20
Mahalia Jackson
- 21
Oleg Cassini & Julie Newmar
- 22
Dorothy Kilgallen
- 23
Tallulah Bankhead
- 24
Barrie Chase
- 25
Bobby Darin (2)
- 26
Genevieve
- 27
The Ritz Brothers
- 28
Nat 'King' Cole (2)
- 29
Gary Crosby
- 30
June Allyson (4)
- 31
Raoul Lévy & Julie London
- 32
Gordon and Sheila MacRae
- 33
Peter Ustinov
- 34
Anna Maria Alberghetti (2)
- 35
Carol Burnett
- 36
Dennis, Lindsay and Phillip Crosby (Sons of Bing Crosby)
- 37
Tony Martin
- 38
Sophia Loren (2)
- 39
Phil Silvers (4)
- 40
Mort Sahl
- 41
George Burns
- 42
Alan King
- 43
Yogi Berra (2)
- 44
Bill Cullen
- 45
The McGuire Sisters (3)
- 46
Eartha Kitt (3)
- 47
Nancy Walker
- 48
Mary Healy and Peter Lind Hayes (2)
- 49
Mitch Miller
- 50
Connie Francis