- 1
Esther Williams (3)
- 2
Branch Rickey & June Allyson
- 3
Claudette Colbert
- 4
Garry Moore
- 5
Dinah Shore and George Montgomery
- 6
Victor Borge & Hedda Hopper
- 7
Gary Cooper
- 8
Phil Silvers (3)
- 9
Harry Belafonte (2)
- 10
Paul Newman and Joanne Woodward
- 11
Fabian
- 12
Dr. Tom A. Dooley & Walter Brennan
- 13
Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II
- 14
Art Carney (2)
- 15
Arlene Dahl (2)
- 16
Maureen O'Hara
- 17
Tom Poston
- 18
George Jessel (2)
- 19
Jack Paar
- 20
Nelson Eddy (2)
- 21
Julie Andrews
- 22
Peter Lorre (2)
- 23
Charles Laughton (2)
- 24
Peggy Lee (2)
- 25
Gisele MacKenzie
- 26
Arthur and Kathryn Murray
- 27
Shelley Winters (2)
- 28
Jane Fonda
- 29
Jack Lemmon (2)
- 30
Jonathan Winters
- 31
Bob Cummings (2)
- 32
Laurence Harvey
- 33
Gertrude Berg (2)
- 34
James Cagney
- 35
June Allyson
- 36
Jane Wyman
- 37
Bobby Darin
- 38
Van Johnson (3)
- 39
Ingemar Johansson (2)
- 40
Elaine May and Mike Nichols
- 41
The Trapp Family Children (from the Broadway Musical)
- 42
Shelley Berman
- 43
Jerry Lewis (2)
- 44
General William C. Westmoreland & Zsa Zsa Gabor
- 45
Myrna Loy
- 46
Arnold Palmer & Dina Merrill
- 47
Jesse Owens
- 48
Buddy Hackett (2)
- 49
Bette Davis (2)