- 1
Marisa Pavan
- 2
Ernie Kovacs & Edie Adams
- 3
William Bendix (2)
- 4
June Taylor and Her Dancers & William Holden
- 5
George Stevens & Claudette Colbert
- 6
Sal Maglie & Ann Miller
- 7
Jo Stafford
- 8
Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe & Bishop Fulton J. Sheen
- 9
Charlton Heston
- 10
Jack O'Brian & Beatrice Lillie
- 11
Walt Disney
- 12
James Kilgallen (Father of Panelist Dorothy Kilgallen) & Nanette Fabray
- 13
Charles Laughton
- 14
Milton Berle
- 15
Dimitri Tiomkin & Shelley Winters
- 16
Floyd Patterson & Vincent Price
- 17
Steve Allen and Jayne Meadows
- 18
The Harlem Globetrotters & Bert Lahr
- 19
Yul Brynner
- 20
Robin Roberts & Robert Montgomery
- 21
George Gobel
- 22
Salvador Dalí & Lillian Roth
- 23
Tab Hunter
- 24
General Alfred Maximilian Gruenther & June Haver and Fred MacMurray
- 25
Mike Todd & Ginger Rogers
- 26
Robert Wagner
- 27
Robert Mitchum
- 28
Charles Boyer
- 29
Dr. Norman Vincent Peale & Judy Holliday
- 30
Mamie Van Doren
- 31
Hedy Lamarr
- 32
Ted Atkinson & Fernando Lamas
- 33
Michael Romanoff & Helen Hayes
- 34
Robert Young (2)
- 35
Jimmy Piersall & Paul Douglas
- 36
Mickey Rooney (2)
- 37
Walter Brennan
- 38
Ann Sothern (2)
- 39
Sammy Davis Jr. (2)
- 40
Eddie Cantor and Daughter Marilyn Cantor Baker
- 41
Johnnie Ray (2)
- 42
Peggy Lee
- 43
Gene Kelly
- 44
Sal Mineo
- 45
Buddy Hackett
- 46
Lew Hoad & Shelley Winters and Anthony Franciosa
- 47
Julius LaRosa (2)
- 48
Anne Jeffreys and Robert Sterling
- 49
Jayne Mansfield
- 50
Edie Adams & Jane Russell
- 51
Zsa Zsa Gabor (2)
- 52
Gene Tierney