- 1
Buster Keaton (2)
- 2
Ernie Kovacs & Doris Day
- 3
Erle Stanley Gardner & George Sanders
- 4
Patti Page
- 5
Henry J. Kaiser & Julie London
- 6
Danny Thomas
- 7
Elsa Maxwell & Pat O'Brien
- 8
Irene Dunne (2)
- 9
Spring Byington
- 10
Jack Lemmon
- 11
Gale Storm
- 12
Eva Gabor (2)
- 13
Margaret O'Brien (2)
- 14
Errol Flynn
- 15
Phyllis Cerf (Wife of Panelist Bennett Cerf) & Joan Crawford
- 16
Sophie Tucker
- 17
Cyril Ritchard
- 18
Jolie Gabor & Anthony Perkins
- 19
Pat Boone
- 20
Duke Snider & Robert Cummings
- 21
Ralph Bellamy (2)
- 22
Abbe Lane & Xavier Cugat
- 23
Congressman James Roosevelt & Patrice Munsel
- 24
Phil Silvers (2)
- 25
Milton Berle (2)
- 26
Judy Holliday (2)
- 27
Lena Horne (2)
- 28
Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller & Jack Paar
- 29
Sir Hubert Wilkins & Mary Healy and Peter Lind Hayes
- 30
Anita Ekberg
- 31
Hope Lange & Don Murray
- 32
John Perona & Greer Garson
- 33
Bob Hope
- 34
Jane Powell
- 35
Gracie Fields (2)
- 36
Tennessee Ernie Ford
- 37
Miyoshi Umeki
- 38
Steve Allen (2)
- 39
Olivia de Havilland
- 40
Betty Hutton (2)
- 41
Fred Astaire (2)
- 42
Bob Crosby
- 43
Andy Griffith
- 44
Sophia Loren
- 45
Benny Goodman (2)
- 46
Dorothy Lamour (2)
- 47
Kathryn Grayson
- 48
Esther Williams (2)
- 49
Van Cliburn
- 50
Althea Gibson
- 51
Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gormé
- 52
Dick Powell
- 53
Polly Bergen