- 1
Eva Marie Saint
- 2
Ed Sullivan (2)
- 3
Jane Wyatt and Robert Young
- 4
Roy Rogers
- 5
Darryl F. Zanuck
- 6
Joe E. Lewis (2)
- 7
Gordon MacRae
- 8
Imogene Coca
- 9
Robert Wagner (2)
- 10
Raymond Berry & Charles Boyer
- 11
Edmund G. Brown & Harry Belafonte
- 12
Anna Maria Alberghetti
- 13
Thomas Schippers & Jose Ferrer
- 14
Kathryn Grant (Mrs. Bing Crosby)
- 15
Jayne Meadows (2)
- 16
Celeste Holm (2)
- 17
Joseph Cotten
- 18
Richard Boone
- 19
Paul Newman
- 20
Ingemar Johansson & Burl Ives
- 21
Marge and Gower Champion (2)
- 22
Maria Schell
- 23
Johnny Mathis
- 24
Noël Coward
- 25
Fred MacMurray (3)
- 26
Sammy Davis Jr. (3)
- 27
Lana Turner
- 28
Cornelia Otis Skinner
- 29
Jeanne Crain (2)
- 30
Frankie Laine (2)
- 31
Hermione Gingold
- 32
Andy Griffith (2)
- 33
Milton Berle (3)
- 34
Franklin Heller & Pat Suzuki
- 35
Debbie Reynolds (2)
- 36
Gypsy Rose Lee (2)
- 37
The McGuire Sisters (2)
- 38
Anthony Perkins
- 39
Jack Benny (2)
- 40
Ruby Goldstein & Red Buttons
- 41
William Bendix (3)
- 42
Eartha Kitt (2)
- 43
The Andrews Sisters (2)
- 44
Cliff Arquette (as Charley Weaver)
- 45
Eddie Hodges
- 46
Julie London
- 47
Archie Moore & Suzy Parker
- 48
Tony Randall
- 49
Ricky Nelson